Concept Note


Exploring Subjectivity: Mind, Body, Action


Baidik Bhattacharya, Udaya Kumar, V. Sanil

We encounter the words ‘subject’, ‘subjective’ and ‘subjectivity’ frequently in discussions of literature. ‘Subjective,’ is often used for describing an individual’s private experience or opinions as different from ‘objective,’ measurable or verifiable facts. Sometimes the word ‘subject’ is applied to those who perform actions; but the word is equally used for those who experience situations, emotions, or feelings. Many critics consider authors as the ‘subjects’ of literary works; some look at readers as the ‘subjects’ of literary experience; and readers of stories tend to regard characters as subjects. The aim of this workshop is to get a clearer sense of the varied uses of words clustered around the idea of ‘subjectivity’ and explore what questions we can ask with them, and what new perspectives or approaches they give rise to. To grasp the concept of the subject, it is useful to see how it is related to and different from other concepts in its neighbourhood—such as ‘person,’ ‘self,’ and ‘agent.’

There is a tendency to regard human subjectivity as mental, belonging to the inner domain of human life. The French philosopher Descartes was probably referring to something of this kind when he said “I think, therefore I am.” The inner lives of human beings are not only about thinking in a rational sense. Literature, as all of us know, is known for exploring many dimensions of this, like emotions, feelings, sensations, thoughts, dreams and fantasies. Many of these aspects of subjectivity do not even belong to our conscious life. How do each of these domains of inner life affect our conception of the subject?

The ‘Copernican turn’ in western enlightenment philosophy shifted the stand point of ‘thinking’ to that of the subject. Our knowledge of reality, according to this view, is dependent on our relationship with reality. In other words, the ‘I’ is an unsubstitutable perspective on the world. However, it is only one among many such perspectives. Still, we discover the laws of nature, enter into morally binding relationship with others, and express ourselves sincerely. How are these possible? Readers and students of literature are familiar with this question. The play of the ‘first person’ and ‘third person’ points of view in narratives and the tensions in lyric poetry between a preoccupation with the self and the address to the reader are marks of this.

What is subjectivity? Is it the experiential life that presupposes self consciousness? Can we understand this experience as self reflection and introspection? The irreducible subjective dimension of experience does not preclude the challenges to the notion of a unified self. Modernist writers such as Joyce, Woolf, Kafka and Beckett may be seen as trying to find a form of writing that works with such lack of unity. The embeddedness of the self in “one’s own body” and in social practices open up the horizon of intersubjectivity. Who is this Other: someone like me, another self?

Our knowledge of ourselves and others is not exhausted by inference or induction. A clear understanding of this knowledge seems to be necessary for giving an account of a spectrum of emotions ranging from love, empathy, hate to shame and humiliation. Self-understanding does not mean that we are present to ourselves as an object or fact in an immediate manner. The self could be thought of as an accomplishment. The narrative conception of the self provides a normative account of the self as an act. Is the idea of narrative adequate to render the intensity of our encounter with novelty in the world, the radical difference of the other, and the trauma and suffering experienced by the self? These questions enable us to look afresh at literary texts and forms of life writing that bear testimony to traumatic events that render narration impossibly difficult.

The idea of the subject has often been associated with action, as the ‘doer behind the deed.’ Philosophers like Nietzsche have questioned this approach. There are so many different kinds of actions, ranging from those that are consciously intended and planned to inadvertent or accidental ones and to things we do without reflecting, out of habit. Actions are not carried out in an empty world; they take shape in a world where desires, moral values, social norms and conventions, chance events and accidents exert their force. Literature from ancient times to our own—from the Mahabharata and Greek tragedies to science fiction and fantasy narratives—has explored ways in which human beings are implicated in chains of action and what this reveals about human subjectivity.

An area where the subject has been prominently studied in recent years is in relationship to structures of power. Traditionally power is seen as constraining human beings and limiting their freedom. Challenging this view, thinkers like Michel Foucault argued that power relations are everywhere, and that subjects are not outside this field; it would be more useful to see subjects as produced by power. Exploring this link allows us to analyze different forms of subjectivity in relation to history and location. For example, a woman subject in nineteenth century England or a gay subject in twenty-first century America or a Dalit subject in contemporary India may be understood in deep interrelationship with configurations of power that shape gender, sexuality and caste in these places and times. People do not always accept existing power relations and their effects; they also resist domination. Looking at various kinds of resistance is hugely useful and fascinating in the study of subjectivity.

Another way of thinking about subjectivity or the self is to anchor it in its most immediate locale—i.e. the human body. Building on a long tradition of European philosophy on subjectivity and the body—that is premised on the complex relationship between ‘having’ a body and ‘being’ that body—scholars in recent decades have shown how critical readings of the body can lead to a more nuanced understanding of the way subjects or selves are formed. The body is our primary opening to the world of objects, senses, and thoughts—as such, it is the experience of embodiment (being one’s body) that gives us access to our lifeworlds. However, the body itself is not an innocent or unmarked object/self, as it is often defined through various categories like gender/sexuality, class, caste, ethnicity, religion, disability and so on. Or, as in cultural studies and other disciplines, the body is often described as ‘enthralled’ to given power regimes and their specific cultural and social codifications. As a result, though we often stage certain identities on our bodies (think of caste markers, or use of tattoos or piercing, or even cross-dressing), we also need to be conscious of the imperceptible limits of our self-fashioning placed on us by different regimes of power. Literary texts, films, philosophical discourses, and political movements allow us to understand this essential duality of the body—you may think of classic novels like Robinson Crusoe or Frankenstein, or more recent texts like The Hunger Games or Disgrace; or political movements like Dalit movements, temple entry movements like Sabarimala, or even ‘pinjra tod.’ It is useful to explore these ideas around the body and subjectivity in conjunction with questions of power, affect, sexuality, and technology.

You will find below two lists of readings on these questions and themes. We would like all workshop participants to read all the essays listed as ‘Essential Readings.’ ‘Further Readings’ allow more in-depth and advanced exploration, and we strongly recommend them to those of you who are interested in the topics and areas they address. This note and the readings given below are aimed at helping you in formulating a topic for your essay. It is useful for the essay to have a specific and sharp focus, be that on literary texts or concepts or cultural phenomena, or an interweaving of the three. A very general theme or idea may make it difficult to develop your analysis and argument with clarity and precision. Hope you enjoy writing your essay and participating in the workshop.

Look forward to seeing you in March.

She just wants to sleep. The plane 9A0-152 VCE lasted two hours later, waiting for the luggage time MB5-538 Practice Exam dragged too long. The 1Y0-A23 Study Guide Book airport shuttle bus MB5-538 Practice Exam also missed 251-250 PDF the moment, the bus 251-250 PDF as early as an hour ago 9A0-152 VCE DMDI201 Exam Practice PDF already drove away. So, they DMDI201 Exam Practice PDF have 9A0-152 VCE to wait for a taxi now. She stood in the waiting line, slim body due to the weight of the laptop tilted to one DMDI201 Exam Practice PDF side. John talked about interest rates and new ideas for adjusting DMDI201 Exam Practice PDF business partners, MB5-538 Practice Exam but she only thought of one thing it is Friday night 251-250 PDF at ten thirty, I want to wear pajamas, the United States and the United States to sleep. A yellow taxi endless stream passing her 9A0-152 VCE MB5-538 Practice Exam eyes. 251-250 PDF These MB5-538 Practice Exam cars are similar 9A0-152 VCE in color and shape, reminding her of insects. She remembered her when he was a child in the mountains. When she and her brother spotted a broken badger or kicked a red ant nest, she saw a 1Y0-A23 Study Guide Book large group of limbs and hands 1Y0-A23 Study Guide Book and feet wet wriggling DMDI201 Exam Practice PDF on the ground. This chilling feeling made her shiver. A taxi speeding over, 251-250 PDF with a sharp brake sound abrupt halt. Tami Joan Kefas 9A0-152 VCE dragged forward. Driver press the trunk lock, 1Y0-A23 Study Guide Book but people did not move in the car. John was 251-250 PDF upset that they had to get their luggage on board. He is 9A0-152 VCE used to having others MB5-538 Practice Exam help him with these things. Tami Joan does not matter. Until now, she occasionally will be surprised, I actually have 1Y0-A23 Study Guide Book a secretary, help her typing and file management. She threw the suitcase onto the car, closed the trunk lid, and got into the car. John followed suit. He shut the door heavily, wiping his fat cheeks and his MB5-538 Practice Exam bare forehead as hard as he had done with his luggage. First to East 72nd Street. John murmured to the driver through the bulkhead. Then go to Upper West Side, MB5-538 Practice Exam Tami Joan added. Block the plexiglass partition between the front and rear seats covered with scratches, she could hardly see the driver. Taxi arrows MB5-538 Practice Exam rushed off MB5-538 Practice Exam the 251-250 PDF road and quickly ran up the highway to Manhattan. Look, John said. Thats why people are 251-250 PDF everywhere 9A0-152 VCE today. 9A0-152 VCE He pointed to a billboard that read Welcome to the United 1Y0-A23 Study Guide Book Nations Peace Conference. Shakes finally remembered the first of the police officers arriving at the scene to adapt to the fourth rule P is to protect the scene of the murder. Angry horn started 1Y0-A23 Study Guide Book flooding the air in the early morning misty, quickly mixed into the drivers roar MB5-538 Practice Exam angry. A moment later, she heard sharp DMDI201 Exam Practice PDF sirens also joined the dissonant MB5-538 Practice Exam noise, and the 251-250 PDF first police car arrived. Forty minutes 251-250 PDF later, the DMDI201 Exam Practice PDF scene was already packed with uniformed police and criminal detectives, 251-250 PDF more than the usual number of murders in Hells DMDI201 Exam Practice PDF Kitchen the famous crime 1Y0-A23 Study Guide Book zone in New Yorks DMDI201 Exam Practice PDF West End 1Y0-A23 Study Guide Book A lot 1Y0-A23 Study Guide Book 9A0-152 VCE 9A0-152 VCE of. In view of the shocking DMDI201 Exam Practice PDF death of the victim, sending so many DMDI201 Exam Practice PDF people does not seem excessive. However, Shakesi heard from other police officers that this was a big case and 251-250 PDF a media concern - the 1Y0-A23 Study Guide Book deceased was one of a group MB5-538 Practice Exam of travelers arriving DMDI201 Exam Practice PDF at JFK last night and they made a taxi into the city, But 251-250 PDF never got home. CNN is 251-250 PDF reporting on the spot, the uniformed police officer whispered to her. So when Emilia Shakesh saw the handsome Vince Piriti, DMDI201 Exam Practice PDF the head of the Criminal Investigation 9A0-152 VCE and Resource 1Y0-A23 Study Guide Book Scheduling MB5-538 Practice Exam Team climbed to the top of the embankment overlooking the crime scene and 9A0-152 VCE 1Y0-A23 Study Guide Book stopped to beat him from time to time It is not particularly surprising when it comes to 9A0-152 VCE the dust on suits of thousands of dollars. However, she was surprised. Piriti actually noticed her, and waving her past. He smoothed a little in his shaven clean face. She thought she would 9A0-152 VCE probably be applauded 251-250 PDF for the extraordinary performance of todays unruffled. Well done, saved the fingerprint on the iron ladder Maybe it will give her a little reward. The last hour on duty 1Y0-A23 Study Guide Book on the last day. She will leave MB5-538 Practice Exam with glorious 251-250 PDF DMDI201 Exam Practice PDF glory. He looked up and down at her. Policewoman, you are not a novice, right 1Y0-A23 Study Guide Book I think I will not mistake. Im DMDI201 Exam Practice PDF sorry, sir Youre not a newbie, DMDI201 Exam Practice PDF Im sure. 1Y0-A23 Study Guide Book Strictly speaking, she can not be considered. Although she entered the police only a short period of three years, unlike her MB5-538 Practice Exam other police at this age, most have nine to ten years of seniority. Before entering the police academy, Shakesi had been in society for several years. I do not understand what youre trying to ask. He seemed annoyed and the smile on his face 9A0-152 VCE disappeared. Are you the first policeman to arrive at the scene Yes, sir.